Appraised Value vs Market Value: Key Differences in Home Pricing

When it comes to home valuations, terms like appraised value and market value can be confusing, but they’re both crucial for homeowners. Understanding these two can help you make informed decisions whether you’re buying, selling, or refinancing your home.

• Appraised value refers to the estimate a professional appraiser provides after evaluating your home. Lenders use this figure to decide how much to loan a buyer. It’s based on the home’s location, condition, and any upgrades you’ve made.
• On the other hand, market value is what buyers are willing to pay for your home. It’s influenced by factors like demand, local competition, and even current economic trends. Unlike the appraised value, market value fluctuates with the market.

Want to find out your home’s current value? You can get an instant valuation at iBuyer.com.

Appraised Value: Factors Lenders and Buyers Consider

When determining your home’s appraised value, a licensed appraiser plays a critical role. Their evaluation is crucial because lenders rely on it to ensure they’re not lending more than the home is worth.

The appraised value is influenced by several key factors:

• Location: The neighborhood, local amenities, and proximity to schools or transportation affect how much your home is worth.
• Condition: Homes that are well-maintained with updated systems (like plumbing or electrical) tend to appraise higher.
• Upgrades: Significant improvements like kitchen remodels, new flooring, or energy-efficient windows can boost a home’s appraised value.

Appraisers conduct a thorough inspection, comparing your property with similar homes in the area. They also consider current market trends, but their focus remains on the home’s characteristics rather than buyer demand. This value is what lenders use when setting mortgage limits, so it’s essential to understand how it’s calculated.

Market Value: What Drives Homebuyers’ Price Willingness

Market value is all about what a buyer is willing to pay for your home. Unlike the appraised value, which focuses on the home’s condition and features, market value is heavily influenced by buyer demand, competition, and the overall economy.

Several factors shape a home’s market value:

• Current trends: If the housing market is hot, homes can sell for much higher than expected. In a seller’s market, limited supply and high demand drive prices up.
• Buyer competition: Multiple offers on a home often push the price higher. Buyers may be willing to pay more to outbid others, especially if the property checks all their boxes.
• Economic conditions: Interest rates, inflation, and employment rates can all impact how much buyers are willing to spend.

Real-life example: In some neighborhoods, homes may sell above the asking price because buyers are competing to secure the property, even if its appraised value is lower. Ultimately, market value is what the market dictates at a given time, and it can change quickly depending on these external forces.

The Biggest Gaps Between Appraised and Market Value

It’s common for homeowners to see differences between appraised value and market value. These two figures can diverge significantly, and it’s important to understand why this happens and what it means for you as a seller or buyer.

Here are some key reasons why appraised and market values often don’t match:

• Market conditions: In a competitive housing market, buyers may offer more than the appraised value, driving up the market value. An appraiser may value the home based on past sales, while the market value reflects current buyer demand.
• Buyer sentiment: Sometimes, buyers fall in love with a home and are willing to pay a premium, regardless of the appraisal. Features like a stunning view or unique architecture might be valued more by buyers than appraisers.
• Appraisal limitations: Appraisers follow strict guidelines and base their evaluations on recent sales and the home’s physical condition. They won’t consider the emotional appeal or urgency that might push buyers to offer more.

For example, in a booming real estate market, a home may receive multiple offers well above the appraised value. However, the lender may only approve a loan based on the appraisal, leaving the buyer to cover the difference or renegotiate.

Handling Market Value Surpassing Appraised Value in Home Deals

When the market value of a home exceeds its appraised value, it can create complications for both buyers and sellers. If a lender won’t loan more than the appraised amount, buyers might need to come up with extra cash or renegotiate. But don’t worry—there are solutions.

Here’s how to navigate this tricky situation:

• Renegotiate the price: Sellers might agree to lower the sale price to match the appraised value. This can keep the deal moving forward, especially if both parties are eager to close.
• Pay the difference in cash: Buyers can choose to cover the gap between the appraised value and the higher market value. This option is more common in competitive markets where buyers are willing to pay extra to secure the home.
• Dispute the appraisal: If you believe the appraisal was too low, you can request a reconsideration or get a second appraisal. However, there’s no guarantee that a new appraisal will come in higher.
• Look for alternatives: Some buyers may explore options like a higher down payment or different loan terms to make the deal work, especially if they’re committed to buying the home.

Ultimately, handling this gap requires flexibility, communication, and understanding of the current market. Buyers and sellers who are open to compromise often find ways to close the deal successfully.

Reilly’s Two Cents

As someone who’s been through the home buying process more than once, I’ve seen firsthand how frustrating it can be when appraised value and market value don’t align. One time, I found my dream home, but the appraisal came in significantly lower than the asking price, and it nearly derailed the whole deal.

Here’s what I learned from my experience:

1. Review the appraisal report carefully: Don’t just accept the appraiser’s word for it. Look for any mistakes or outdated comparisons. If something seems off, ask questions.
2. Request a second appraisal: If you truly believe the appraisal was unfair, you can push for a second one. While there’s no guarantee of a higher value, it’s worth trying if the numbers don’t add up.
3. Negotiate smartly: Whether you’re the buyer or seller, be open to negotiation. Sellers can lower the price or offer incentives, while buyers can agree to cover part of the gap in cash. The key is staying flexible.

Every home deal is unique, but understanding your options and staying calm during the process can save you time and money.

Final Thoughts: Securing the Best Deal in Today’s Market

Understanding the difference between appraised value and market value is key to navigating today’s real estate market smoothly. While appraised value is important for securing a mortgage, market value is what truly drives transactions, influenced by buyer demand and competition.

By knowing both, you’ll be better equipped to handle negotiations and avoid surprises. If you’re selling, keep in mind that buyers may rely on an appraisal, but they could also be willing to pay more if the market is hot. For buyers, don’t be discouraged by a low appraisal—there are ways to make the deal work without breaking the bank.

Whether you’re buying or selling, you can make smarter decisions when you understand these values and their role in the process. If you want a hassle-free way to sell your home, check out iBuyer.com for an instant valuation and cash offers that let you skip the uncertainty altogether.

Common Questions About Home Valuations